According to Consumer Affairs, most car starters are built to last between 100,000 and 150,000 miles. While the exact mileage will depend on your driving habits and the condition of other components, there's inevitably a time when you'll need to replace yours.

However, you shouldn't just buy any replacement starter. By upgrading to a high-quality part, you can improve reliability, performance, and even longevity of vehicle ignition systems. So while this may cost you more in the short term, it may save you money in the long run.

But how can you pick the right replacement starters? This article will be your automotive starter guide.

Signs You Need a New Starter

First of all, how do you even know when your starter's failing? You don't want to replace it prematurely, but you don't want to put unnecessary wear and tear on your vehicle either.

These are the key signs that your starter is failing:

• Clicking noise when turning the key
• Grinding sounds during startup
• Engine cranking slowly or inconsistently
• Occasional failure to start, even with a charged battery
• Visible smoke or burning smell from the engine bay

If you notice any of these signs, then it's time for a car starter replacement.

What Are the Best Types of Replacement Starters?

The good news is that there are several starter motor options available, so you're not stuck with just one choice. Let's go over the main types you can consider.

OEM Replacement Starters

OEM replacement starters are a good option for stock vehicles, as they restore original performance. They have a perfect fit and factory specs.

However, these aren't always ideal for budgets, upgraded engines, or extreme conditions.

High-Torque Performance Starters

High-torque performance starters are best for modded vehicles and harsh conditions. There's extra cranking power, yet the starters have compact and durable designs.

These starters can:

• Handle high compression engines
• Withstand heat
• Have smaller footprints

The downside is that they tend to be more expensive. They're also unnecessary for stock vehicles.

Gear Reduction Starters

Gear reduction starters are ideal for old-school builds or if you have space constraints. They have a small size but have increased torque by using a gear drive.

These starters have less battery draw, and they're reliable in older vehicles. But since they have a slightly more complex design, they require careful installation.

Remanufactured Starters

These are great if you're on a tight budget, as remanufactured starters are cost-effective. They're refurbished with OEM specs, making them both budget-friendly and eco-friendly.

The one drawback is that there's variable reliability, depending on the remanufacturer. So always do your research and choose premium remanufactured units with solid warranties.

How to Choose the Right Starter for Your Vehicle

Now that you understand replacement starters more, your next concern is how to choose the right one. Here are the key steps to follow.

Identify Your Vehicle's Specifications

The vital information you'll need here are:

• VIN
• Make
• Model
• Engine displacement
• Transmission type (manual or automatic)
• Year

Don't skip this essential step. If you get the wrong starter, then you'll have fitment issues, misalignment, and electrical incompatibility.

Determine Your Needs

Next, analyze your driving conditions. This will determine which type of replacement starter will be ideal for you.

For example, if you drive a compact car for city commuting, then a direct OEM or aftermarket replacement would be best for you. But if you drive a pickup truck for off-roading or towing, then you'll need a high-torque performance starter. And a muscle car that's used for street performance could use a gear reduction starter.

Consider Warranty and Support

In general, you'll want a starter that has at least a one-year warranty. Premium brands typically offer warranties like extended periods up to limited lifetimes. As for remanufactured starters, they usually have a one-year warranty, but there are possibilities to opt for longer (which you should take).

Check Brand Reputation and Reviews

Read user reviews to get a feel for how good a brand is. Stick with well-reviewed ones to ensure there's consistent quality.

The criteria you should focus on are:

• Longevity reports
• Ease of installation
• Cold weather performance
• Support from the manufacturer

How to Install a New Starter

For this job, you'll need:

• Socket wrench set
• Screwdrivers
• Jack stands or a lift
• Safety glasses
• Gloves

For your safety, you should work on a cool engine and disconnect the battery first to avoid shock.

Lift the Vehicle

Lower vehicles often require under-car access. So to make your job easier, and for better stability, lift it by using jack stands.

Locate and Remove the Old Starter

The starter should be near the bottom rear of the engine, close to the transmission. If you can't find it, then consult your vehicle's manual or repair guide.

Disconnect the wiring harnesses and battery cable, and then unbolt and remove the old starter. Compare the old with the new and ensure that the following match:

• Mounting points
• Electrical connections
• Gear teeth

Install the New Starter

Now, you can bolt the new starter into place securely; hand-tighten the bolts first, then torque to spec. The starter should seat flush without force.

Reconnect the wiring and battery cable, and then lower the vehicle.

Reconnect the Battery and Test

Reconnect the battery terminals and use dielectric grease on the terminals to help prevent corrosion and ensure strong contact. Start the car and listen for smooth, quick ignition. Avoid long cranking sessions of over 10 seconds.

Choose From the Best Replacement Starters

The next time your vehicle's starter breaks down, upgrade to high-quality replacement starters. Not only will that restore function, but it'll also enhance performance, reliability, and efficiency.

There's always a starter tailored to your needs; you just have to do your research and consider your driving purposes. If you take the time to carefully weigh your options, then you'll have fewer breakdowns and smoother starts for years to come.

Browse our selection of starters today to get started. Every starter that DB Electrical sells meets EOM standards, and you'll typically get up to 30% off retail OEM prices. We also have free same-day shipping for orders over $50!

Related Articles

Kohler Engine Parts: How to Find the Right Fit Fast
Installing a New Starter for Kohler: A DIY Repair Guide